Pools are excellent places for relaxing and entertaining. However, they require regular sanitation to keep the water sparkling clear and algae-free.
Two popular systems we install at Ritzcraft Pools & Pavers include standard, manually added chlorine and saltwater pools. Each system has unique pros and cons, which can help you decide which type would best suit your needs.
What’s the Difference Between the Two Choices?
Both choices add the necessary chlorine to your pool — the main difference is the form it comes in.
Chlorine Pools
This type of swimming pool needs chlorine added directly in the form of a liquid, tablet or granules. The chlorine dissolves in the water, keeping it clear of bacteria and algae blooms and ready for fun all summer.
Saltwater Pools
If you have a saltwater pool, you’ll need to add pool-grade salt to it, which a salt chlorine generator then converts into chlorine automatically and will do so as long as the system is running.
Benefits of Saltwater vs. Chlorine Pools
Both options have pros and cons involving costs, maintenance and swimming experience.
Saltwater Pool Pros and Cons
Saltwater is gentler on swimmers’ skin and eyes, requires less manual upkeep because of continuous chlorination and has lower ongoing chemical costs. However, it has higher installation costs and requires professional service for the complex salt chlorine generator system.
Chlorine Pool Pros and Cons
You’ll benefit from lower initial setup costs for a chlorine pool and straightforward upkeep. As these pools are more common than saltwater pools, chlorine is widely available. They require adding chlorine regularly and striking a delicate balance with pH levels between 7.2 and 7.8. Otherwise, the water can cause skin and eye irritation.
Chlorine Pool vs. Saltwater Maintenance
Both types of pools require regular water testing for pH and alkalinity, with chlorine pools needing more hands-on maintenance to maintain proper levels. Saltwater pools require more salt as needed when the water is diluted by rainwater, backwashing or splashing.
The chlorine generator uses electrolysis to convert salt into chlorine, but it doesn’t use it up — it recycles it, so only physical dilution of the water causes salt loss. Testing it every few weeks or after severe weather will let you know if you need to add salt.
Is a Saltwater Pool Better Than a Chlorine Pool?
Neither is objectively better than the other — they’re simply different. The one that appeals to you most depends on your lifestyle, budget and maintenance preferences.
Which Pool Is Right for You?
When considering chlorine vs. saltwater for your new pool installation, you should base your decision on what you value most. If you’re looking for a pool installation at a lower cost and have the resources and time to maintain it regularly, a chlorine pool would suit you best. Choose saltwater if you can afford the higher upfront cost and want to think about maintenance less.
At Ritzcraft Pools & Pavers, we install new builds and remodel pools with custom water features in the Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte County areas. Our customers love our work because it’s high-quality, and we treat people how we want to be treated — with respect, friendliness and professionalism.
Contact us online today or call for a free consultation.